Home / Blog / Logic puzzles / Advanced Sea Battle Puzzle Techniques for Harder Grids

Advanced Sea Battle Puzzle Techniques for Harder Grids

Last updated: .

Easy Sea Battle grids fall to the numbers and the water around ships. Harder grids have fewer given squares, and you must reason about where the big ships can go. These advanced Sea Battle puzzle techniques come from a real Expert grid, solved square by square. If you are new to the puzzle, start with the beginner strategies.

What Hard and Expert change

Both levels use a 10 x 10 grid and the fleet of ten ships: one of four squares, two of three, three of two and four single squares. The generator adds given squares only until a solver can finish by reasoning. In the Hard level it adds one square more than that strict minimum and, when it adds a square, it gives a piece of ship six times out of ten. The Expert level adds none, and gives a piece of ship only one time out of four, so most of its given squares are water. A grid with so little given is solved by counting.

The grid

This Expert grid has five given squares: the left end of a ship in row 1, column 3, the bottom end of a ship in row 2, column 9, the right end of a ship in row 5, column 4, a single ship in row 8, column 6, and a square of water in row 9, column 1. Rows are counted from the top and columns from the left.

An Expert Sea Battle puzzle (10 x 10, ten ships) and its solution. Download the printable PDF

Technique 1: read the shape of the grid

Before you place anything, read all the numbers. Column 8, column 10 and row 10 all show 0: that is 28 squares of water before any reasoning. Column 9 shows 7, which is huge for a 10-square line. Because the two columns beside it are water, every ship that touches column 9 must lie along it, or be a single square. So the seven ship squares of that column are vertical ships and singles stacked in one line, and the numbers say that this line is nearly full.

A high number is a gift: it leaves little choice. A column or row that shows more than half of its length tells you where the long ships are before you have any given piece near them.

Technique 2: count the places of the biggest ship

The ship of four squares is the hardest to hide, because it needs a line whose number is at least 4. Check the numbers. Only row 1 (4) and column 9 (7) are high enough. Row 1 already has three ship squares, in columns 3, 4 and 9, so it cannot hold a ship of four. The ship of four is in column 9.

Now find where, using what you know about the bottom of the column. Row 9 shows 3, and only three of its squares are not water, in columns 2, 3 and 9, so all three are ship squares. Row 8 shows 2: its given single in column 6 is one, and the only open square is column 9. So column 9 holds ships in rows 1, 2, 8 and 9, and row 10 is water. A ship of four in rows 4 to 7 would touch the ship in row 8, and rows 5 to 8 would touch the ship in row 9. Only rows 6 to 9 are left, so the ship of four is column 9, rows 6 to 9.

Technique 3: let a finished ship close itself

A ship that has reached the length of the biggest ship left cannot grow. Once the four squares of column 9 are placed, the square above them, row 5 column 9, is water. Now count column 9 again. It shows 7, and it has the two ships at the top (rows 1 and 2) and the four you just placed: that is 6. Row 3 and row 5 are water, so the only open square left is row 4, column 9: a ship of one square. Row 4 shows 1, so the rest of row 4 is water.

TechniqueWhat it placed
Read the numbers (0 lines, column 9 = 7)28 water squares; column 9 is a vertical line
Count the places of the biggest shipThe ship of four in column 9, rows 6 to 9
Let a finished ship close itselfWater in row 5 column 9, then a single ship in row 4 column 9
Several ships of the same lengthTwo ships of three: row 1 columns 3 to 5, row 5 columns 2 to 4
Where each technique came from in this grid.

Technique 4: several ships of the same length

The fleet has two ships of three squares, and neither is placed yet. Count the places where a ship of three can lie. After the deductions above, only two remain: row 1, columns 3 to 5, which extends the ship that starts at the given end in column 3, and row 5, columns 2 to 4, which extends the given end in row 5. Every other line of three squares is blocked by water, by a number that is already used, or by contact with another ship, and that includes the stretch along row 3 and the stretch along row 1 to the right of column 5. When the number of places is equal to the number of ships left, every place is used. So row 1 column 5 and row 5 column 2 are ship squares.

From there the lines finish by themselves: row 1 shows 4 and now has all of them, row 5 shows 3 and has all of them, and the last ships are found by counting the open squares in rows 3 and 6 and in columns 1 and 6.

A method for 100 squares

  • Mark water first, in pencil, everywhere you are sure: 0 lines, then every square around a ship. A grid with many dots is easy to read.
  • Write the fleet beside the grid and cross off ships as they become certain, so you always know the biggest ship left.
  • After each batch of marks, check every row and column against its number: how many ship squares it has, how many it still needs, how many open squares are left.
  • Only then count the places of the biggest ship left. If you find none, a mark is wrong; if you find one, you have your next move.

Tip

Our suggestion, not a rule: when a count does not work, do not erase everything. Look at the most recent ship you placed. A single wrong ship is usually the last one, and a corner it touches is the clue.

To make a book of Hard and Expert Sea Battle grids, with a solution for each, create a free account and open the Sea Battle assistant. The basics of the puzzle are in the Sea Battle puzzle rules.

Create a free account to make a full book

Create a free account to make a book with the Sea Battle assistant. The assistant puts at most two puzzles on a page, because the fleet is drawn under each grid.

Questions

Do Hard and Expert grids use the same fleet?

Yes: ten ships on a 10 x 10 grid (4, 3, 3, 2, 2, 2, 1, 1, 1, 1). The difference is the number and kind of given squares: Hard gives one more than the strict minimum, Expert none, and Expert gives mostly water.

Do I ever need to guess in an Expert grid?

No. Each grid is built so that a solver using the reasoning on this page finds every ship, and we solved the grid in this article with a separate program that never guesses.

What is the best way to avoid mistakes in a big grid?

Keep the fleet list up to date and check every new ship against its row and column numbers before you go on.

Sources

Want to publish your own puzzle book?

LogikLand generates Sudoku, crossword, word search and maze books for Amazon KDP, in 8 KDP trim sizes from 5 x 8 to 8.5 x 11 inches, plus A4 and 8.5 x 8.5 square, exported as a PDF or an editable PPTX file. Commercial rights come with the PRO and EXPERT plans.

Related: All blog articles | Try the tool | All free puzzle generators | More Logic puzzles articles