Advanced Sudoku X techniques start where scanning ends. You have placed every digit that rows, columns, boxes and diagonals force, and the grid still has holes. In Sudoku X the way out often goes through the grey diagonals. This article shows three techniques on three real positions made by the LogikLand generator, each ending with a new digit.
When scanning stops working
We solved 40 hard and 40 expert Sudoku X grids with a program that may use only: the only place for a digit in a group, cells with a single candidate, locked candidates and naked pairs. Here is what happened:
| Level | Grids solved | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Hard | 40 of 40 | 18 grids needed locked candidates, 9 grids needed naked pairs |
| Expert | 0 of 40 | These techniques are not enough |
How the diagonals meet the boxes
The geometry explains everything. Each diagonal meets every row and every column in exactly one cell, so a diagonal and a row never trap a digit together. But each diagonal passes through exactly three boxes, and in each of them it covers three cells. The main diagonal (top left to bottom right) crosses boxes 1, 5 and 9. The other diagonal crosses boxes 3, 5 and 7. Box 5, the centre one, is shared by both. You still use the usual overlaps of a box with a row or a column, as in classic Sudoku. The new ones are the overlaps of a diagonal with a box, and they are always three cells wide.
Technique 1: the diagonal pins a digit in a box
This is a hard grid with 37 digits on the page, the position you reach after every simple placement:
Look at the digit 5 on the main diagonal. Row 1, column 1 is out because there is a 5 in column 1 (row 3). Row 9, column 9 is out because there is a 5 in row 9 (column 8). Rows 2, 3, 7 and 8 of the diagonal hold 8, 6, 2 and 4. That leaves three cells: row 4 column 4, row 5 column 5 and row 6 column 6, and all three are in box 5.
So the 5 of the main diagonal is inside box 5, and that means box 5's own 5 is on the diagonal. Cross out the 5 in the other cells of box 5: row 4 columns 5 and 6, row 5 column 6, and row 6 column 5.
Now look at the other diagonal. Its empty cells for the digit 5 are row 3 column 7, row 4 column 6, row 5 column 5 and row 7 column 3. Row 3 column 7 sees the 5 in row 3, row 7 column 3 sees a 5 in column 3, and row 4 column 6 was just crossed out. Only row 5, column 5 is left: it is a 5.
Technique 2: the box pins a digit on the diagonal
The same overlap works backwards. Here is a second hard grid, with 42 digits shown after the single placements:
Where can box 5 take a 9? Row 4 column 6 and row 6 column 4 both lie on the other diagonal, which already has a 9 in row 2 column 8, so they are out. Row 5 columns 4 and 6 are out too, because row 5 has a 9 in column 7. That leaves row 4 column 4 and row 6 column 6, two cells of the main diagonal.
The 9 of box 5 is therefore on the main diagonal, so the diagonal's 9 is inside box 5, and no other cell of the diagonal can be a 9. Cross it out in row 3 column 3 and row 9 column 9. Row 3 now has one place left for its 9, in row 3, column 1.
Technique 3: a naked pair on a diagonal
If two cells of a group can only hold the same two digits, those digits are used up for the rest of the group. Here is a position that needs exactly that:
Check the cell in row 2, column 2. Its row, column, box and the diagonal already show 1, 2, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9. Only 3 and 4 are left. The cell in row 7, column 7 shows exactly the same digits, so it can only be 3 or 4 as well. Both are on the main diagonal. One of them is the 3 and the other is the 4, so no other cell of the diagonal can be 3 or 4. In row 5, column 5 the possible digits were 3, 4 and 5; now only 5 is left, and you write a 5.
Where to look first
- Begin with box 5. Both diagonals cross it. We looked at 75 hard positions where one locked-candidate elimination was enough to unlock a digit: 27 of them involved a diagonal, and 13 of those 27 were in box 5.
- Then look at the corner boxes 1, 3, 7 and 9, where one diagonal runs through three cells.
- For each missing digit on a diagonal, count its possible cells. If they all lie in one box, apply technique 1.
- For each missing digit in a box, check whether its possible cells all lie on one diagonal, and apply technique 2.
- Only when these fail, look for pairs among the cells that have two candidates.
Expert grids
None of the 40 expert grids we tested could be completed with the techniques above. LogikLand grades them as needing advanced techniques or trial. Our suggestion, not a rule: put expert grids in their own section at the end of a book and say so on the rules page, so that your readers choose them on purpose.
Keep going
For the basics, see how to solve Sudoku X. The same locked-candidate idea is used on irregular regions in advanced Jigsaw Sudoku techniques. The Sudoku X assistant is available with a free account; see the Sudoku book generator page for the plans.
Questions
Are these techniques the same as in classic Sudoku?
The ideas are the same: a digit confined to the overlap of two groups, and two cells that share two candidates. Sudoku X only adds two more groups, the diagonals, so there are more overlaps to examine.
Do I need to write all the candidates in every cell?
No. Each example below needs only the candidates of one digit in one group. Write small marks only where a technique asks for them.
Does the generator guarantee that hard grids use only these techniques?
Hard grids are graded as needing single-candidate cells and eliminations at most. We tested 40: every one was solved with the techniques of this article.
Related articles
- Printable Easy Sudoku X Puzzles (Free PDF)
Six easy Sudoku X grids to print, with a free PDF and a table of where each puzzle starts.
- Sudoku X Rules: How to Play (With a Printable Example)
The Sudoku X rules, a grid with both diagonals checked by hand, and proof that the diagonals are not optional.
- Sudoku X for Seniors: How to Start (Printable Sample)
How to use Sudoku X with senior readers: a worked first step, the Large Print settings and the right levels.
- Printable Easy Killer Sudoku Puzzles (Free PDF)
Five printable easy Killer Sudoku grids with solutions in a PDF, what each one offers at the start, and how to check your answers.
- What Makes a Sudoku Hard? Difficulty Levels Explained
Why Sudoku difficulty levels depend on the techniques needed as well as the digits given, with two real grids and measured data per level.
- Printable Easy Jigsaw Sudoku Puzzles (Free PDF)
Six easy Jigsaw Sudoku grids you can print today, with a free PDF and a guide to starting each one.
Sources
Want to publish your own puzzle book?
LogikLand generates Sudoku, crossword, word search and maze books for Amazon KDP, in 8 KDP trim sizes from 5 x 8 to 8.5 x 11 inches, plus A4 and 8.5 x 8.5 square, exported as a PDF or an editable PPTX file. Commercial rights come with the PRO and EXPERT plans.
Related: All blog articles | Try the tool | All free puzzle generators | More Sudoku articles