Home / Blog / Sudoku / What Makes a Sudoku Hard? Difficulty Levels Explained

What Makes a Sudoku Hard? Difficulty Levels Explained

Last updated: .

Sudoku difficulty levels look simple: easy, medium, hard. But what makes a Sudoku hard is not a single number. A grid is hard when the moves that finish it are hard to see. This article explains the two things that decide a level, shows two grids that have the same number of digits and very different difficulty, and gives the measurements of the LogikLand classic Sudoku generator, level by level.

Two things that make a Sudoku hard

The first is the number of digits given at the start. With 42 digits, nearly every empty cell is forced by a few neighbours. With 24 digits, you have to do much more work before a cell is forced.

The second is the technique needed. Some grids can be solved from beginning to end with one idea: in a row, column or box, find the digit that has only one possible place. Others require ideas that most players learn later: eliminating digits with aligned cells or pairs, and for the hardest grids, patterns such as X-Wing, XY-Wing or Swordfish. A grid can have few digits and still be solved with the first idea, or have more digits and need the later ones.

Two grids, the same number of digits

Both grids below are expert grids from the LogikLand generator and both have exactly 24 digits given. Each has one solution. A script tried to solve them with four techniques, from the simplest to harder ones.

Grid A: 24 digits. Solved with the only-place technique alone.
Grid B: 24 digits. Not finished by any of the four techniques.

Grid A can be completed by only looking for the single place of a digit in a row, column or box, again and again. Grid B gets stuck: after the first techniques the script could not place another digit, so a human solver needs something stronger or a trial. Same count of digits, very different grids. This is why serious Sudoku sites rate a puzzle by the techniques it needs, and not only by its digits.

The ladder of techniques

GradeWhat you need to do
0Find the only place for a digit in a row, column or box
1Also: spot cells where only one digit is possible
2Also: remove candidates with aligned cells (locked candidates) and pairs
3Something more advanced, or trial and error
The four grades of the grading program in LogikLand's puzzle engine, which also grades Sudoku X and Jigsaw.

On the printable evil Sudoku page, levels are defined the same way. A diabolical puzzle needs at least one advanced technique (X-Wing, XY-Wing or Swordfish), and an evil puzzle is one the checking program could not finish even with those. The six puzzles of that page have 24 to 30 digits given.

Sudoku difficulty levels, measured

The classic Sudoku generator of LogikLand has seven levels. Its rule is simple: it keeps removing digits as long as the solution stays unique, until it reaches the target for the level. We generated 100 grids for each of the first five levels and graded each with the four-technique program above. The two top levels, expert and insane, keep fewer digits still and are meant for experienced solvers.

LevelTarget digitsAverage digitsGrade 0Grade 1Grade 2Grade 3
Very easy4242.0100000
Easy3737.099100
Medium3434.093124
Hard2929.07510411
Very hard2626.039141037
100 classic 9 x 9 grids per level (very easy to very hard), generated and graded by script on October 18, 2026.

Read the table this way. Up to easy, the grids are nearly all grade 0: finishable with the only-place technique. From hard, more and more grids need other techniques.

Two notes on the method. The grids are random, so another run would give slightly different numbers, but the shape would be the same. And grade 3 does not mean the grid is impossible without guessing: it means that these four techniques did not finish it. A skilled player with X-Wing or chains may well solve it by logic.

Choosing levels for a book

Our suggestion, not a rule: when you plan a book, go up one level at a time. A book with an easy section, a medium section and a hard section gives readers the feeling of progress. Keep the expert and insane levels for a final section or for a book aimed at experienced solvers, and try a few grids yourself before you choose.

Get a feel for it first

The free Sudoku sample generator on the Sudoku book generator page needs no account, and the evil Sudoku printable page has six very hard grids to try. Create a free account to make a full book.

Rating a grid you hold

  1. Count the digits. As a rule of thumb, under 26 expect a hard grid and above 36 an easy one, but keep in mind that the count alone can mislead.
  2. Try to solve it using only the single place of a digit. If it works to the end, the grid is grade 0, however few digits it has.
  3. If you need to note candidates, you are at grade 1 or 2.
  4. If you must compare two cells or two rows to remove candidates, you are at grade 2. If that fails, you have a grade 3 grid.

The same grading logic also sets the levels of other variants: see how to solve Sudoku variants and advanced Sudoku variants techniques.

Questions

Does fewer given digits always mean a harder Sudoku?

No. Fewer digits usually make a grid harder, but two grids with the same number of digits can differ a lot, as the two grids above show. The techniques needed matter as much as the count.

What is the smallest number of digits in a puzzle with one solution?

LogikLand does not try to reach a record. Its classic generator aims for between 42 digits (very easy) and 22 (insane), and keeps a grid only if its solution is unique.

Sources

Want to publish your own puzzle book?

LogikLand generates Sudoku, crossword, word search and maze books for Amazon KDP, in 8 KDP trim sizes from 5 x 8 to 8.5 x 11 inches, plus A4 and 8.5 x 8.5 square, exported as a PDF or an editable PPTX file. Commercial rights come with the PRO and EXPERT plans.

Related: All blog articles | Try the tool | All free puzzle generators | More Sudoku articles